Substack Free vs Paid: Understanding the Costs and Benefits

Author

Reads 1.4K

A woman with afro hair working on a laptop while lying on a bed in a cozy home setting.
Credit: pexels.com, A woman with afro hair working on a laptop while lying on a bed in a cozy home setting.

Substack offers a free plan, but it's limited in features and audience reach.

The free plan allows for 6 posts per month, which is a relatively small number compared to paid plans.

On the other hand, paid plans offer more flexibility and customization options, such as the ability to send newsletters to a larger audience, add custom domains, and create exclusive content.

Paid plans also provide more analytics and insights into your audience's behavior, which can be helpful for writers looking to refine their content strategy.

If this caught your attention, see: How to Unlock Paid Content on Website for Free

What Substack Offers

Substack offers a range of features to writers, including the ability to create and manage their own newsletters, set their own prices, and connect with readers.

With Substack, writers can earn money directly from their readers, keeping 90% of the revenue after Substack's 10% commission.

You can customize your newsletter's design and layout to match your brand and style, making it easy to create a unique and engaging experience for your readers.

Credit: youtube.com, The BEST Way to Monetize Your Substack (Most People Get This Wrong)

Substack provides tools to help you grow your audience, including the ability to promote your newsletter on social media and track your readers' engagement.

Substack's analytics feature gives you a clear picture of your newsletter's performance, including open rates, click-through rates, and revenue earned.

You can also use Substack's built-in payment processing, eliminating the need for external payment gateways.

Substack handles the technical aspects, so you can focus on creating high-quality content and engaging with your readers.

Substack's platform is designed to be user-friendly, making it easy to get started and manage your newsletter, even if you have no prior experience.

Understanding the Cost

Publishing on Substack is free if your content is free, no matter how many subscribers you have.

The fees for paid subscriptions on Substack are as follows:

  • Substack's platform fee is 10%.
  • Stripe, the payment processor, charges a credit card fee of 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction fee, and a billion fee for recurring subscriptions of 0.5%.

This means that if you're using Substack's paid subscription feature, you'll be charged a total of 12.9% + $0.30 per transaction fee, or 12.5% for recurring subscriptions.

Subscription Benefits

Credit: youtube.com, Klaviyo Subscription Cost and Benefits

A paid subscription on Substack offers advanced features that allow you to monetize your newsletter. With a paid subscription, you can charge subscribers for access to premium content.

You'll also get access to premium themes, which can help you create a professional-looking newsletter. This is especially useful if you want to create a branded experience for your readers.

One of the benefits of a paid subscription is the ability to earn income from your writing. Paid subscribers are charged a monthly or annual fee to access exclusive content, which can provide a reliable source of income for writers.

Paid subscribers are also more likely to be engaged and invested in the content they receive, which can lead to increased readership and engagement. This can help you build a community around your work and establish yourself as an expert in your field.

With a paid subscription, you can offer exclusive content to subscribers, including access to premium articles, early access to new content, or exclusive interviews and features. This can provide value to your subscribers and incentivize them to continue their subscription.

If this caught your attention, see: Substack Features

Credit: youtube.com, How Much Are My Subscriptions Costing Me? - Consumer Laws For You

Here are some benefits of a paid subscription:

  • Earn income from your writing
  • Build a dedicated audience
  • Offer exclusive content to subscribers
  • Create a professional, branded experience for your readers

By offering exclusive content and creating a professional-looking newsletter, you can incentivize subscribers to continue their subscription and build a loyal community around your work.

Cost to Use

Using Substack is free if you don't charge for your content, no matter how many subscribers you have.

If you do enable paid subscriptions, Substack's platform fee is 10% of your earnings. On top of that, Stripe, their payment processor, charges a credit card fee of 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction.

You can set your own subscription plans, such as monthly or annual, and Substack won't charge you any additional fees.

Readers in Europe may have the option to pay using direct debit or other non-credit card methods.

The fees for using Substack are as follows:

It's worth noting that you can choose to pay using a credit card, and most major credit cards are accepted.

Free vs

A man writing at a desk under dim lighting, concentrating with intent focus.
Credit: pexels.com, A man writing at a desk under dim lighting, concentrating with intent focus.

Free vs paid subscriptions on Substack - it's a crucial decision for writers and creators looking to monetize their content. The good news is that Substack offers both options, allowing you to choose the one that best suits your needs.

If you opt for a free subscription, you won't have to pay anything to use Substack, regardless of how many subscribers you have. However, free subscribers will have limited access to your content and features.

Publishing on Substack is free, but paid subscriptions come with some fees. Substack's platform fee is 10%, and Stripe, the payment processor, charges a credit card fee of 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction, as well as a billion fee for recurring subscriptions of 0.5%.

Here's a breakdown of the fees you can expect:

While free subscriptions have their limitations, they can still be a great way to get started on Substack. But if you want to monetize your content and grow your subscriber base, a paid subscription is the way to go.

Publishing and Subscriptions

Credit: youtube.com, Why EVERYONE should be on Substack | What it is, How it Works, $$$

You can publish posts to either "Paid subscribers only", "Free subscribers only", or "Everyone", giving you control over who sees your content.

When you turn on paid subscriptions, you'll have an additional option to publish only to Founding members if you've enabled the Founding member plan.

Publishing to "Paid subscribers only" means the post will be sent out by email only to your paid subscribers and will have a lock icon to indicate it's a paid post.

Posts published to "Everyone" will be sent out by email to both paid and free subscribers, and will appear on your publication page.

Publishing to "Free subscribers only" will send the post out by email only to your free subscribers, and it won't appear on your publication page.

You can turn on paid subscriptions and still publish all your content for free, making paid subscriptions a voluntary way to support you.

Publications that paywall at least some of their content make on average five times as much revenue as publications that publish all their content for free.

Here's a breakdown of the options you'll have when publishing with paid subscriptions:

Comparison and Case Study

Credit: youtube.com, Substack Grow: Strategizing free vs. paid content

The "Morning Brew" newsletter offers a free subscription option that includes daily news updates, but also includes ads. This model has allowed them to reach a wider audience.

Having a free option doesn't mean you can't generate revenue, as "Morning Brew" shows. They make money through advertising and premium content.

The paid version of "Morning Brew" is ad-free and includes exclusive content and events. This is a key benefit that sets it apart from the free version.

On the other hand, the "Sinocism" newsletter takes a paid subscription approach. It includes access to exclusive content, a weekly podcast, and a private Slack community.

Despite being paid, "Sinocism" has a large and dedicated audience due to the quality of its content and the expertise of its author.

Reader Perspective

As a reader on Substack, you might be wondering what this means for you. Honestly, I'm trying not to force any decisions here.

The writer likes being a reader on Substack and values the community of writers. They also appreciate the minimal style of the platform.

Unless you come up with a specific plan or reason to move off the site, it's probably best to just stick with it.

Why I'm Disillusioned

Person Writing on a Notepad Beside a Laptop
Credit: pexels.com, Person Writing on a Notepad Beside a Laptop

I'm disillusioned with Substack because I bought into the idea that it was a platform for paid subscription-based newsletters, but it turns out that's not entirely true.

The community on Substack is where I got lost, and I became all wrapped up in the social media aspect of it, thinking I was building a community and promoting others' work.

People who are already on Substack are primarily writers who can afford to pay for very few subscriptions, so it's not a profitable platform for me.

I wrote about realizing I needed to decide if I was on Substack for community or income, but I wanted it to be both.

I chose Substack because I believe in the subscription newsletter model and people investing in a mission, not just a product.

I put my own money towards supporting others on Substack and elsewhere, but it's hard to sustain that financially.

What Does This Mean for Me?

An Elderly Man Sitting while Writing on Notebook
Credit: pexels.com, An Elderly Man Sitting while Writing on Notebook

As a reader, it's natural to wonder what the changes mean for you. One thing is certain: Substack will continue to be a community of writers, and it's still a great platform for reading.

The writer values the community aspect of Substack and enjoys being a reader here. They also appreciate the minimal style of the platform.

You can expect the newsletter to be treated as originally intended - a newsletter designed for paying subscribers. This means you'll still get exclusive content, but the writer will also look for ways to promote it outside of Substack.

Post Discussion

Some writers offer a pay per view option, but it's not a common practice.

People can cancel automatic renewals on paid yearly subscriptions, but it's easy to forget to do so.

The pay per view option is not necessary, as some writers have found that offering the same content to both free and paid subscribers can be effective.

In fact, one writer has a higher than average pay to free ratio, suggesting that people are willing to pay for quality content.

A "Buy Me A Coffee" link can generate significant one-time donations, even for writers who have been around for a long time.

Understanding

Credit: youtube.com, What Is Substack & How Does It Work

Substack is a platform that allows writers to publish newsletters and earn money from subscriptions. It offers both free and paid options, but understanding the differences between them is crucial for writers who want to monetize their content.

The free plan on Substack allows writers to create and publish newsletters, but it comes with limitations. Writers can only send newsletters to up to 600 subscribers for free, and they won't be able to see their email open rates or click-through rates.

Substack takes a 10% commission on all paid subscriptions, but writers can still earn a significant income by building a loyal audience. For example, a writer who earns $100 per month from 100 subscribers would still take home $90, minus the 10% commission.

Writers on the free plan can upgrade to a paid plan at any time, and they can also switch back to the free plan if they need to. This flexibility is a key advantage of Substack's pricing model.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the downside of Substack?

Limited design control and a lack of customization options can make Substack emails appear less visually appealing. This can make it harder for your content to stand out in a crowded inbox.

Bessie Fanetti

Senior Writer

Bessie Fanetti is an avid traveler and food enthusiast, with a passion for exploring new cultures and cuisines. She has visited over 25 countries and counting, always on the lookout for hidden gems and local favorites. In addition to her love of travel, Bessie is also a seasoned marketer with over 20 years of experience in branding and advertising.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.