
The United States has a complex internet censorship landscape, with multiple stakeholders vying for control. The federal government, state governments, and private companies all play a role in shaping online content.
The Communications Decency Act of 1996 is a landmark law that prohibits certain types of content online. This law has been amended several times, with the most significant changes occurring in 2000.
The Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) is another important law that regulates online content. COPPA requires websites and online services to obtain parental consent before collecting personal data from children under the age of 13.
Internet service providers (ISPs) in the US can also engage in internet censorship. For example, some ISPs have been known to throttle speeds for certain types of online content.
Intriguing read: Stop Online Piracy Act
Worth a look: Telecommunications in Kyrgyzstan
Federal Laws and Regulations
Federal laws generally bar governments from directly censoring the Internet, except in cases of obscenity, including child pornography.
The Communications Decency Act (CDA) was enacted in 1996 to regulate indecency and obscenity online, but the anti-indecency provisions were deemed unconstitutional in 1997.
Section 230 of the CDA remains in effect, protecting Internet service providers (ISPs) from liability for the words of third parties and for good faith actions taken to restrict access to certain materials.
Communications Decency (CDA)
The Communications Decency Act (CDA) is a federal law that aimed to regulate online content, specifically indecency and obscenity. The CDA was enacted in 1996.
In 1997, the Supreme Court ruled that the anti-indecency provisions of the Act were unconstitutional, citing that they placed an unacceptably heavy burden on protected speech. This decision effectively struck down the law's attempts to regulate online content.
However, a separate portion of the CDA, known as Section 230, remains in effect. Section 230 protects Internet service providers (ISPs) from liability for the words of third-party users and also shields them from liability for good-faith efforts to restrict access to certain offensive materials.
Discover more: Digital Services Act
Cyber Intelligence Sharing & Protection
The Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act, or CISPA, was a bill that aimed to give the government more tools to protect network security. It was first introduced in 2011.
CISPA was supported by a long list of companies, including AT&T, Facebook, and IBM, as well as trade groups like the Business Software Alliance and the United States Chamber of Commerce. These organizations believed the bill would help them protect their networks from cyber threats.
The bill was also backed by major tech companies like Intel and Oracle Corporation. However, not everyone was on board with CISPA.
Reporters Without Borders expressed concerns that CISPA would allow the government and private companies to monitor and even censor the web. Other organizations, like the American Civil Liberties Union and the Electronic Frontier Foundation, also opposed the bill.
National Firewall and Restrictions
The US government has been exploring ways to restrict access to certain online services and data. The RESTRICT Act would allow the Secretary of State to review tech companies suspected of sabotaging the US and restrict them if national security risks are found.
In 2020 and 2023, the government attempted to ban social media app TikTok. The DATA Act would have banned the selling of non-public personal data to third-party buyers, but it's unclear if this would have affected TikTok specifically.
Violations of the RESTRICT Act could result in fines of up to $1,000,000 or up to 20 years in prison for US citizens.
For your interest: United States Government Group Chat Leaks
Will the U.S. Implement a National Firewall?
The idea of a national firewall has been debated for years, but it's a complex issue with pros and cons.
The U.S. government has considered implementing a national firewall to protect its citizens' online data, but it's not a new concept. The concept of a national firewall has been around since the 1990s.
A national firewall could potentially block malicious traffic and cyber threats, but it could also slow down internet speeds and stifle innovation.
The Chinese government has implemented a national firewall, known as the Great Firewall of China, which blocks access to certain websites and online services. This has raised concerns about censorship and free speech.
See what others are reading: National Internet Registry
Restrict Data
The RESTRICT Act would allow the government to review any tech company's actions and potentially restrict them if they're deemed a threat to national security. This could mean investigating and possibly banning any site the government considers a risk.
In 2023, the US government considered restricting a social media app, likely TikTok, under the RESTRICT Act. This bill would give the Secretary of State and other departments the power to review and restrict companies, services, or products with "security risks".
Violations of the RESTRICT Act could result in a fine of up to $1,000,000 or up to 20 years in prison for US citizens who don't comply.
Court Rulings
In April 2022, a District Judge issued a site blocking order against three piracy websites.
The order mandated that the three websites, as well as any newly-discovered websites operated by the defendants, be blocked by all US ISPs.
This order prohibited any third-party service operator from doing business with or offering services to the defendants.
Their domain names were ordered to be seized and transferred to the plaintiffs.
This order is similar to, but goes beyond what was proposed in SOPA.
Schools and Libraries
Schools and libraries are often at the forefront of internet censorship debates in the US. Many K-12 schools and libraries accept federal funds for internet access and are required by CIPA to have an "Internet safety policy and technology protection measures".
Internet filters are commonly used in schools to block material deemed inappropriate, but decisions about what to filter or block are left to local authorities. Critics argue that this approach can lead to overblocking of useful information, and underblocking of harmful information.
A 2003 study found that blocking software overblocked state-mandated curriculum topics - for every web page correctly blocked, one or more was inappropriately blocked. This can be frustrating for students and teachers who need access to reliable information.
Some libraries block access to certain web pages, including pornography, advertising, chat, gaming, social networking, and online forum sites. The use of filtering and blocking software in libraries remains a contentious issue.
In 2007, a US District Court issued a restraining order forbidding activists from posting links to allegedly leaked documents about Eli Lilly and Company. The Electronic Frontier Foundation appealed, arguing that citizen-journalists should have the same First Amendment rights as major media outlets.
The Deleting Online Predators Act of 2006 would have required schools, some businesses, and libraries to block minors' access to social networking websites. This bill was widely criticized for potentially limiting access to many websites with harmless and educational material.
See what others are reading: Blocking of Twitter in Brazil
Individual Websites and Services
Individual websites and services often implement their own forms of censorship, banning or requiring pre-approval of content that violates their policies.
Some websites restrict speech that they consider to be hate speech more broadly than is required by US law, and may also restrict speech that they consider to be harassment and verbal abuse.
Social media platforms may have different policies on what constitutes hate speech and harassment, leading to inconsistent and often subjective enforcement of these rules.
The English Wikipedia shut down for 24 hours in 2012 to protest the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA), which would have allowed the US Department of Justice to seek court orders against websites accused of enabling or facilitating copyright infringement.
Websites like Amazon can also choose to cut off services to certain websites, as they did with WikiLeaks in 2010 after being contacted by Senator Joe Lieberman.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation defended WikiLeaks in the Bank Julius Baer vs. WikiLeaks lawsuit, which resulted in a permanent injunction against the website's domain name registrar, but was later lifted.
Individual websites and services can have a significant impact on online freedom of expression, and their policies can often be at odds with US law and international human rights standards.
Preventing Online Censorship
Online censorship in the US is a complex issue, but there are steps you can take to protect your online freedom. The Communications Decency Act of 1996, as explained in the article, provides a framework for online content regulation, but it also gives internet service providers (ISPs) the power to block or censor content.
One way to prevent online censorship is to use a virtual private network (VPN) when accessing the internet. This can help mask your IP address and location, making it harder for ISPs to track and censor your online activity. According to the article, VPNs are not always foolproof, but they can provide an added layer of protection.
In addition to using a VPN, you can also support organizations that advocate for online freedom and oppose censorship. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) is one such organization that has been fighting for online civil liberties since the 1990s.
Worth a look: Declaration of Internet Freedom
Protecting Cyberspace Asset
The Protecting Cyberspace Asset Act generated controversy in 2010 for what critics perceived as its authorization for the US president to apply a full block of the Internet in the US.
The Executive Cyberspace Coordination Act of 2011 took a different approach, but the details of this alternative are not provided in the available information.
The Protecting Cyberspace Asset Act was part of a larger debate about online censorship and the balance between security and individual freedoms.
The US Justice Department would have maintained two publicly available lists of domain names under the Combating Online Infringement and Counterfeits Act, with the second list containing domains alleged to be infringing but against which no action had been taken.
This list would have allowed service providers to block access to sites without fear of prosecution, but critics argued that this was a form of censorship.
The Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act (CISPA) also aimed to enhance network security, but its provisions were criticized by organizations such as Reporters Without Borders, which expressed concern about government and private company monitoring of the Web.
CISPA was supported by major telecommunications and information technology companies, including AT&T, Facebook, and Verizon, but was opposed by organizations such as the American Civil Liberties Union and the Electronic Frontier Foundation.
Expand your knowledge: List of Mobile Network Operators in the United States
Interruption of Services
The interruption of services is a critical aspect of online censorship, and it's essential to understand the laws and regulations surrounding it. In 2014, the FCC issued an Enforcement Advisory warning the public that using a cell phone jammer or any device that blocks or interferes with authorized communications is illegal.
The California Law Revision Commission issued a recommendation in 2016 on government interruption of communication services, concluding that government action can be constitutional if it follows specific procedures. These procedures include obtaining judicial approval, finding probable cause, and ensuring the action is necessary to protect public health, safety, or welfare.
In extreme emergencies, prior judicial approval is not required, but the government must still follow the Emergency Wireless Protocol (EWP) established by the federal government. This protocol requires state and local government officials to initiate an interruption of communication service through the National Coordinating Center for Communications (NCC) within the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).
Broaden your view: Communications in Madagascar
A general interruption of communication service that affects a large number of people or a large geographic area requires judicial approval and must meet specific conditions. These conditions include being necessary to avoid a serious threat of violence, being content-neutral, and impairing no more speech than is necessary.
The EWP also sets out the process for interrupting and restoring wireless communication service during times of national emergency. This process involves the NCC issuing orders to private providers, which must then take action to interrupt communication services.
A fresh viewpoint: Internet Service Providers Association (United Kingdom)
Preventing Online Censorship
Online censorship can be prevented through various means.
One way to prevent online censorship is to use a Virtual Private Network (VPN), which can mask your IP address and location, making it difficult for censors to track your online activities.
Using a VPN can also help you access blocked websites and content.
The Tor browser is another tool that can help prevent online censorship by routing your internet traffic through a network of servers, making it hard to track your online activities.
Readers also liked: List of Mobile Virtual Network Operators in the United States
Some governments and organizations have used internet shutdowns as a means of censorship, which can be devastating for people who rely on the internet for communication and access to information.
In 2019, an internet shutdown in Sudan resulted in a loss of $3.5 million in revenue for the country's economy.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is censorship in the United States?
Censorship in the US refers to the suppression of speech, communication, or information deemed objectionable, harmful, or sensitive. This can be implemented by governments, institutions, or individuals to control what information is shared or accessed.
Featured Images: pexels.com


