Golang Gorm Alternative: A Comprehensive Comparison and Guide

Author

Reads 1.2K

Close-up of colorful programming code displayed on a computer screen.
Credit: pexels.com, Close-up of colorful programming code displayed on a computer screen.

Golang's Gorm library is a popular choice for database interactions, but it's not the only option. Beego ORM, a lightweight alternative, offers a more streamlined approach to database management.

Beego ORM's simplicity makes it a great choice for small to medium-sized projects. It's also relatively easy to learn, even for developers new to Golang.

One key advantage of Beego ORM is its ability to automatically generate CRUD (Create, Read, Update, Delete) operations. This means less boilerplate code for developers, allowing them to focus on more complex tasks.

In contrast, Gorm requires more manual setup for CRUD operations.

Performance Comparison

The performance of a database package is crucial for data-centric applications, especially those with low-latency requirements. Benchmarks consistently show that pgx outperforms GORM by 30-50% in high-throughput systems due to factors like no reflection overhead and direct native support for PostgreSQL types.

GORM initially outperforms other libraries in fetching small record sets, but trails significantly as the record count increases. sqlx performs consistently in third place, but lags behind sqlc and database/sql as data size increases.

The database/sql and sqlc packages perform well across all six cases in benchmarks, with sqlc proving to be slightly faster than database/sql as the number of records fetched increases to 10,000 and 15,000 records.

Benefits Over

A developer working on a laptop, typing code, showcasing programming and technology skills.
Credit: pexels.com, A developer working on a laptop, typing code, showcasing programming and technology skills.

GORM is the most popular ORM on the list, based on GitHub stars, with 29.4k stars and 3.3k forks.

It's developer-friendly and supports many databases, including MySQL, MSSQL, PostgreSQL, SQLite, and more.

GORM's ease of use makes it a great choice for beginners to experts.

If you prefer a schema-first approach, SQLBoiler is a good option, as it's primed for type safety and is performant and intuitive.

SQLBoiler supports MySQL, MSSQL, PostgreSQL, SQLite, and Cockroach DB.

SQLC and SQLX are good choices if you're comfortable with the database/sql package and need extra functionalities.

Both SQLC and SQLX make using the database/sql library worthwhile.

The Beego ORM is popularly used with the Beego framework and supports MySQL, SQLite, PostgreSQL, and more.

GORP and Go-firestorm are also worth considering, especially if you prefer the code-first approach or are working with the Google Cloud Firestore.

Performance and Speed

Performance and speed are crucial factors to consider when choosing a database package for your Go application. Benchmarks consistently show pgx outperforming GORM by 30-50% in high-throughput systems.

Computer Program Language Text
Credit: pexels.com, Computer Program Language Text

To get a better understanding of performance and speed, a benchmark was run on a MySQL/MariaDB database with 15,000 student records. The benchmark captured the performance of all 4 database packages fetching 1, 10, 100, 1000, 10,000, and 15,000 records and scanning them into structs.

Here's a summary of the benchmark results:

The results show that GORM outperforms the rest of the libraries for the first two tests of 1 and 10 records, but trails significantly as the record count increases. sqlc performs quite consistently in third place in terms of performance, better than GORM, but it usually lags shortly behind sqlc and database/sql when data size increases.

The database/sql and sqlc packages perform very well across all six cases in benchmarks. As the number of records fetched increases (to 10,000 and 15,000 records), sqlc proves to be slightly faster than database/sql.

Explicit Control and Customization

Explicit Control and Customization is crucial for any database interaction. sqlc lets you write native SQL, which is as expressive as you need, and still benefit from type-safe Go code generation.

Credit: youtube.com, Go & GORM: Remove ID field and review gorm.Model usage (project based example)

Having explicit control means you get to decide the query plan, indices, and joins, not the ORM. sqlc gives you this control.

GORM's migration system is rudimentary and often relies on auto-migrate at runtime, which is risky in production. Atlas, on the other hand, offers a declarative SQL migration system that tracks schema state and generates migration scripts safely.

Building your own ORM from scratch can be a viable option, as demonstrated by someone who successfully built their own ORM using a Lego analogy.

Alternative Solutions

If you're looking for alternatives to GORM, you have a few options to consider. SQLBoiler is one such alternative, a schema-first ORM that generates type-safe models from your defined database schema. It provides functionalities for complete model generation, eager loading, and raw SQL fallbacks, among others.

SQLx is another alternative that extends the features of the standard library database package. It offers prepared statements with named parameters, struct scanning, and support for IN queries, among other features. This can be a good option if you want to leverage the database/sql package while still gaining some additional benefits.

If you're interested in exploring other options, you might also want to take a look at xo and sqlc, which are two other database-first code generators. However, it's worth noting that these tools may not offer the same level of support for associations between tables as SQLBoiler does.

On a similar theme: Create a Package in Golang

Dynamic Sql

Credit: youtube.com, Mastering Dynamic SQL: How to Dynamically Call a Column in the WHERE Clause

Dynamic SQL can be a challenge with some alternative solutions. pggen doesn't have the same level of support for dynamic SQL as ORMs and query builders, making it difficult to generate dynamic SQL on the fly.

Static SQL is often enough for most use cases, but dynamic SQL is necessary for faceted search and other scenarios where the exact SQL and query parameters are determined at runtime. pggen's generated Scan methods on model structs can still be used for loading result sets, but this approach can be less elegant than others.

Some engineers find the string templating required for dynamic SQL with pggen as easy to reason about as chained GORM calls, while others find it more cumbersome. This highlights the importance of choosing the right tool for the job.

Other Database-First Code Generators

SQLc is another database-first code generator that's worth considering. It takes a schema-first approach and generates type-safe code from SQL to interact with SQL databases with Go data types.

Related reading: Golang Source Code

Programming Language on a Screen
Credit: pexels.com, Programming Language on a Screen

The SQLC package provides database queries, transactions, configurations, and functionalities, making it easy to use if you've worked with the sql package before. It's also worth noting that SQLc is an SQL compiler ORM package that generates type-safe code from SQL.

xo and gnorm are two other database-first code generators that were considered, but they didn't seem like a good fit for pggen's requirements. This is because pggen aimed to offer a gradual offramp from GORM and provide good support for associations between tables.

A fresh viewpoint: Install Golang Package

Sqlx

Sqlx is a Go library that extends the database/sql package for more efficient and comprehensive interactions with databases. It provides functionalities for marshaling rows into structs with embedded struct support, and marshaling into maps and slices, prepared statements, and more.

The SQLX package is backward-compatible and extendable, making it easy to use with the database/sql package and many other ORM packages. It takes the schema-first approach, which is useful if you're not a fan of full-featured ORMs.

Credit: youtube.com, Understanding sqlx.Next and sqlx.StructScan: Are They Safe for Concurrent Use?

Sqlx shines in several areas, including prepared statements with named parameters, struct scanning, and select and get methods. These features enable you to use the names of struct fields and map keys to bind variables in a prepared statement or query.

Here are some key features of sqlx:

  • Prepared statements with named parameters
  • Struct scanning
  • Select and Get methods
  • Support for IN queries
  • Named queries

Sqlx also supports error-free result sets, which allows for chainable operations on returned results, such as scanning results directly into a struct. This can be seen in the following snippet:

Sqlx makes it easier to work with queries using the IN clause, as it treats IN bindvar values as multiple values, not a single value.

Beego

Beego is a powerful ORM that's inspired by popular Python ORMs, making database interactions in Go a breeze. It's part of the Beego web framework, one of the most popular frameworks in the Go ecosystem.

The Beego ORM takes a code-first approach, which is similar to how GORM works. It provides support for interacting with MySQL, PostgreSQL, and SQLite3 through popular drivers.

Readers also liked: Golang Go

Two women working together on code at a computer in a modern office setting.
Credit: pexels.com, Two women working together on code at a computer in a modern office setting.

Beego ORM supports all Go data types, making it a versatile tool for database interactions. It also supports database queries, table joins, and raw SQL queries.

One of the advantages of Beego ORM is that it provides command line functionalities that are missing in GORM. This makes it a great option for developers who prefer working with the command line.

Developers who use the Beego framework for building web apps often prefer Beego ORM due to its ease of use and powerful features.

Related reading: Golang Line

Comparison and Selection

Choosing a Go ORM can be a daunting task, especially with so many options available. GORM stands out as a mature, feature-rich ORM, while Prisma Client Go shines in ensuring type safety and minimizing repetitive code.

GORM is a solid choice for small to medium projects where quick prototyping is key, thanks to its compatibility with SQL databases and large community (29.4k GitHub stars and 3.3k forks) offering plenty of learning materials and support.

Credit: youtube.com, ORM vs Raw SQL in Go: GORM Database Abstraction Complete Guide

For projects with diverse database requirements, GORM's broad SQL support makes it a practical option. Its native SQL integration also provides flexibility for direct SQL support.

If type safety and maintainability are your priorities, opt for Prisma Client Go. Its schema-first approach ensures full type safety and declarative schema management.

Here's a table comparing the two ORMs:

Ultimately, the choice between GORM and Prisma Client Go depends on your project's needs and your team's workflow preferences.

Gorm Compatibility and Migration

GORM is a widely used database layer in existing services, and any alternative should have a good story for gradually migrating away from it. This is where pggen comes in, a code generator that can seamlessly integrate with GORM.

To migrate a service from GORM to pggen, you need to add a table entry for the given table to the pggen.toml file. This allows pggen to generate the necessary model structs.

pggen includes an escape hatch configuration option that allows you to add arbitrary struct tags to any field in the generated struct. This ensures that migrations from GORM won't be blocked by updates to the pggen tool.

Related reading: Golang Copy Struct

Credit: youtube.com, Setup Gorm Migrations and Fiber Routes

The process of migrating a service from GORM to pggen involves switching all database layer methods to use the new generated model struct. This can be done at the leisure of the development team.

Here are some benefits of using pggen with GORM:

  • You can continue to use GORM and just use pggen to automatically generate the structs for you.
  • You can avoid manual updates when you add new columns to the database.
  • You can seamlessly integrate new code with existing code that works with the model using GORM.

In summary, pggen provides a smooth migration path from GORM, allowing you to gradually move away from it while still utilizing its features.

Prisma and Other Alternatives

If you're looking for a Gorm alternative, Prisma Client Go is definitely worth considering. It follows a schema-first approach, which provides strong type safety.

This approach involves a few extra setup steps, including initializing your Go project, installing the Prisma Client Go module, creating a schema.prisma file, and generating a type-safe client using the Prisma CLI.

To optimize Prisma's performance, you can use OpenTelemetry for tracing, cache frequent queries, and apply serverless best practices when applicable.

Prisma Client Go is a great option for those who prioritize performance and ease of setup. Two critical aspects to consider when comparing ORMs are performance and how easy they are to set up.

If this caught your attention, see: Golang Types

Credit: youtube.com, SQL : Golang gorm - Get relation without using preload

Here's a brief comparison of Prisma Client Go and other alternatives:

Note that while Gorm does not have a schema-first approach like Prisma Client Go, it's still a popular and widely-used ORM for Go.

Claire Beier

Senior Writer

Claire Beier is a seasoned writer with a passion for creating informative and engaging content. With a keen eye for detail and a talent for simplifying complex concepts, Claire has established herself as a go-to expert in the field of web development. Her articles on HTML elements have been widely praised for their clarity and accessibility.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.