
Elasticsearch collapse can occur when a node in the cluster fails, causing the entire cluster to become unavailable.
This can happen when a node is shut down or becomes unresponsive, leading to a cascade of failures across the cluster.
As a result, search performance can be severely impacted, leading to slow or even unresponsive search results.
The cluster's overall health and stability are compromised when a node fails, making it difficult to recover and get back to normal operations.
On a similar theme: Elasticsearch Health
Optimizing Elasticsearch
You can use the `inner_hits` parameter to retrieve additional information about collapsed documents, such as the total number of documents in each group or the highest-rated document in each group.
The `inner_hits` parameter allows you to specify a second level of collapsing in case a sub-grouping of the documents is desired, which is useful when multiple representations of the collapsed hits need to be returned.
To achieve this, you can use the `inner_hits` parameter in conjunction with the collapse feature, and specify multiple `inner_hits` for each collapsed hit.
If this caught your attention, see: Elastic Search Use Cases

In this case, the search results will be collapsed based on the `category` field, and for each collapsed group, the highest-rated document will be returned as an inner hit.
By using the `inner_hits` parameter, you can retrieve additional documents for each collapsed group, which can be useful when you need to display more information about each category.
Each collapsed group will contain the highest-rated document for the category, as well as another sub-grouping for the `subcategory` field, making it easier to drill down into the data.
You might enjoy: Document in Elasticsearch
Handling Results
You can expand each collapsed top hits with the inner hits option to get more detailed information about each group.
The inner hits option allows you to specify multiple inner hits for each collapsed hit, which can be useful when you want to get multiple representations of the collapsed hits. You can request inner hits with different names, sizes, and sorts, such as the three largest HTTP responses and the three most recent HTTP responses for a user.

To control the maximum number of concurrent searches allowed during the expansion of the group, you can use the max_concurrent_group_searches request parameter. The default is based on the number of data nodes and the default search thread pool size.
Track Scores
In Elasticsearch, scores are not computed when collapse is used with sort on a field.
To compute and track scores, you need to set track_scores to true. This instructs Elasticsearch to compute scores.
This is particularly useful in certain scenarios, such as when you want to rank results based on their relevance.
Here are some key points to keep in mind:
- Setting track_scores to true is essential for computing and tracking scores.
- This setting only applies when collapse is used with sort on a field.
By enabling track_scores, you can ensure that your search results are accurately ranked based on their relevance.
Results
If you want to get the top-ranked documents per collapsed field, you can use field collapsing alongside the rescore search parameter. This is achieved by assigning the collapse field value as the routing key during indexing.

Rescorers run on every shard for the top-ranked document per collapsed field, so it's recommended to cluster documents sharing the same collapse field value on one shard. By doing this, you guarantee that only one top document per collapse key gets rescored globally.
You can request multiple inner hits for each collapsed hit to get multiple representations of the collapsed hits. This can be useful when you want to get different types of information about the collapsed hits.
The expansion of the group is done by sending an additional query for each inner_hit request for each collapsed hit returned in the response. This can significantly slow your search if you have too many groups or inner_hit requests.
The max_concurrent_group_searches request parameter can be used to control the maximum number of concurrent searches allowed in this phase. The default is based on the number of data nodes and the default search thread pool size.
Here are some common inner hit options and their uses:
You can use the collapse field value as the routing key during indexing to ensure that only one top document per collapse key gets rescored globally. This helps maintain a reliable order in the search results.
Explore further: Elasticsearch Api Key
Collapsing and Modelling
Elasticsearch offers limited options for expressing relationships between things, unlike a relational database.
In re-platforming realestate listings search using Elasticsearch, three main options were considered for modelling projects and child listings.
Nested-objects modelling projects as single documents containing a nested array of child listings was one option.
Another option was parent/child, modelling projects and child listings as separate documents and taking advantage of Elasticsearch’s support for parent/child relationships.
Field collapsing, storing child listing documents and duplicating project information on each child listing, was the chosen approach.
Field collapsing had the best performance and least impact on the structure of the Elasticsearch queries.
This approach can be useful in creating efficient search experiences, particularly in e-commerce, where deduplication combined with pagination is a challenge.
In Elasticsearch, collapse feature can group hits by a single field to show a single representative result per group.
Here are the three main options for modelling projects and child listings:
- Nested-objects: modelling projects as single documents containing a nested array of child listings.
- Parent/child: modelling projects and child listings as separate documents and taking advantage of Elasticsearch’s support for parent/child relationships.
- Field collapsing: storing child listing documents, duplicating project information on each child listing, and “collapsing” the results on the project id.
Best Practices and Use Cases
Using Elasticsearch collapse can be a game-changer for removing duplicate results and presenting a cleaner result set to the user.
You can group search results by a specific field, such as a category or a tag, to make it easier for users to find what they're looking for.
The collapse feature can be used in conjunction with aggregations to provide a more comprehensive view of the data.
To get the most out of Elasticsearch collapse, use it sparingly, especially when dealing with large datasets.
If this caught your attention, see: Azure Window Gozo Collapse
Best Practices
To get the most out of Elasticsearch, it's essential to use the collapse feature sparingly. Collapsing results can be resource-intensive, especially when dealing with large datasets.
Filters and queries play a crucial role in the effectiveness of the collapse feature. Using filters and queries that accurately target the documents you want to collapse will help improve performance and ensure you get the desired results.
The key to successful use of the collapse feature is to use it only when necessary. This means avoiding the use of the collapse feature for every search query.
Use Cases

The collapse feature in Elasticsearch is a powerful tool that can help you present cleaner and more organized search results to your users. Removing duplicate results is one of the most common use cases for Elasticsearch Collapse.
You can use the collapse feature to group search results by a specific field, such as a category or a tag, making it easier for users to find what they're looking for. This is particularly useful in scenarios where the same document appears multiple times in the search results.
The collapse feature can be used in conjunction with aggregations to provide a more comprehensive view of the data, such as calculating the average rating for each group of products.
Shortcomings and Limitations
Using Elasticsearch Collapse comes with its own set of challenges.
One major shortcoming is that it's impossible to know in advance how many collapsed groups exist. This can be a problem if you're not prepared for it.

You'll need a high precision `cardinality` aggregation or a `terms` aggregation with a large size to get an estimate, but be warned that the latter can impact your cluster's performance.
Collapsing and sorting in the same query requires both to be applied on the same field.
The collapse feature just doesn't work with the scroll API or rescoring.
Suggestion: Elasticsearch Aggregations
Featured Images: pexels.com


