Doxxing Link and the Law: Separating Fact from Fiction

Author

Reads 608

Side view of crop anonymous African American boy having test while teacher explaining information online on laptop
Credit: pexels.com, Side view of crop anonymous African American boy having test while teacher explaining information online on laptop

Doxxing is a serious issue that can have severe consequences for those targeted.

In the United States, doxxing is considered a form of harassment and can be prosecuted under state and federal laws.

Doxxing can lead to physical harm, emotional distress, and even death.

In some cases, doxxing has resulted in the loss of employment, social isolation, and long-term psychological trauma.

Doxxing can also be a form of cyberbullying, which is a growing concern among law enforcement agencies.

Doxxing Laws and Constitution

Doxxing laws can conflict with the Constitution, and this is a major concern.

Anti-doxxing laws often criminalize or impose civil liability for the publication of truthful information, which is a problem because the First Amendment generally protects the publication of truthful information.

The Supreme Court has established a principle that state action to punish the publication of truthful information seldom can satisfy constitutional standards. This is known as the "Daily Mail principle."

This principle ensures that the press, or others who post truthful information, cannot face punishment for publishing the names of rape victims and juvenile offenders, as well as other sensitive information obtained lawfully.

State Laws Addressing

Credit: youtube.com, Legally Speaking: Is Doxxing Legal? | We The Internet TV

State laws addressing doxxing vary in definition, application, and scope. Oregon has enacted an "anti-doxxing" law, but some states don't use the term "doxxing" in their laws.

Washington's law defines doxxing as the unauthorized publication of personal identifying information with intent or knowledge that it will be used to harm the individual. This law focuses on the intent behind the publication.

Illinois' law, on the other hand, focuses on civil liability rather than criminalizing the act of doxxing. This means that individuals can be held liable for damages in civil court.

Alabama defines doxxing as electronically publishing or providing personal identifying information of another individual with the intent that others will use it to harass or harm. This law has a special section that applies to doxxing firefighters and police officers.

Defenders of these laws argue that they are necessary to protect privacy and redress emotional distress and harm caused by those who reveal personal information.

Laws Can Violate the Constitution

Credit: youtube.com, Free Speech and Doxing | Law & Policy | Hoover Institution

Doxxing laws can conflict with the Constitution. This is because they often criminalize or impose civil liability for the publication of truthful information.

Anti-doxxing laws may punish people for sharing accurate information, which is a fundamental right protected by the First Amendment. The Supreme Court has consistently ruled that the press and other publishers cannot be punished for publishing truthful information.

In the case of Smith v. Daily Mail Publishing Co. (1979), the Court held that "state action to punish the publication of truthful information seldom can satisfy constitutional standards." This means that the government cannot punish people for sharing information they obtained lawfully, even if it's sensitive.

Lawfully obtained information includes public records and material in the public domain, not information obtained illegally.

Doxxing and Free Speech

Doxxing laws often ignore the free speech principle that the First Amendment protects much offensive, obnoxious, and even repugnant speech.

The First Amendment also protects publication of truthful information received from a human source, as long as the publisher didn't participate in the illegal action and merely received the information from the source.

Credit: youtube.com, Elon Musk, The Self Crowned 'King Of Free Speech' Bans Doxxing Except When He Wants It Done

Even hurtful speech on public issues is protected to ensure public debate remains uninhibited and robust.

The Supreme Court has explained this principle in cases like Texas v. Johnson (1989) and Snyder v. Phelps (2011).

Some doxxers have exposed online racism spewed by members of police departments, which could be seen as a form of public debate.

The Oregon Court of Appeals dismissed a school board's claims under a doxxing law in the case of DeHart v. Tofte (2023), citing the First Amendment's protection of hurtful and hateful speech.

Doxing government employees is not a gray area, and they don't enjoy special immunity from it. In fact, the power they exercise makes it even more important that people be free to criticize them and disclose information that holds them accountable.

Government officials' actions are subject to public scrutiny, and disclosing their names, contact information, or location can be constitutionally protected speech, especially when tied to political criticism. This is evident in the case of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents, who were publicly identified during President Donald Trump's second term.

Credit: youtube.com, Is Doxxing Illegal? What to Do If You've Been Doxxed

Merely disclosing the names of government agents or places where they carry out their official duties is protected speech. This is not a matter of opinion, but a fact based on the First Amendment.

The location of a government official's home can also be a matter of public concern, as seen in the case of Eric Adams, who ran for New York City mayor in 2021. Journalists investigated whether he actually lived in the city, publishing addresses and photos of his properties.

Doxing is not protected by the First Amendment if it crosses the line into unprotected speech like true threats or incitement or is part of conduct that rises to the level of harassment. However, mere fear that disclosure of truthful information will cause harm cannot justify censorship.

Recommended read: Dropbox Link Doesn't Work

The Threat of Doxxing

Doxing is a serious threat that can have severe consequences. In 2020, Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro's private information was posted on Twitter by the hacking group Anonymous, exposing his financial assets and cabinet members' home addresses.

Credit: youtube.com, What Is Doxing? | 30 STK | NBC News

This targeted online information exposure can lead to physical threats and data security issues. If your organization has high-profile executives or personnel, doxing increases the risk of identity theft and undermines your security posture and reputation.

Doxing can also enable future risks like phishing, which can compromise your organization's security. Threat intelligence can provide a window into the illicit online communities where doxing occurs, helping security teams identify and combat risk.

A doxing example in 2013 involved vigilantes on Reddit wrongly identifying people as suspects in the Boston Marathon bombings. This led to the exposure of Sunil Tripathi's personal information, which was later linked to his tragic death by suicide.

Doxware is a type of malware that carries out doxing extortion via cryptovirology attacks. It was first presented at West Point in 2003 and differs from ransomware in that the victim retains access to their information but its disclosure is at the discretion of the malware.

Doxing can also be used to extort or coerce individuals, and hackers may obtain an individual's dox without making the information public. A survey in 2021 found that 16% of respondents reported suffering doxing due to their online activities.

Preventing and Identifying Doxxing

Credit: youtube.com, What is doxxing and how to avoid it | NordVPN

Doxers follow breadcrumbs across the internet to create targeting profiles for their victims, making it extremely easy to exploit publicly-available information.

The best way to prevent doxing is to pre-empt it by controlling the amount of your personal information that ends up online.

You should always be aware of the private information you are sharing and refrain from publicly providing information such as your address, personal phone number, or email address.

Doxers can exploit information found on your company's website or your executive's social media profile, making it crucial to keep this information private.

Threat intelligence solutions can help security teams find doxing-related intelligence that can help protect your organization and its people against doxes.

Doxing has emerged as a mainstream harassment tactic targeting both high and low-profile victims, making it essential to be proactive in protecting yourself.

Here are some common tactics doxers use to gather information:

  • Emerging tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) that hacking communities are using to dox their targets.
  • Discussions suggesting that a dox targeting your organization could be imminent.
  • Leaked credit cards or other vulnerable information found on paste sites.
  • Patterns of life found on an executive's social media page.

By being aware of these tactics and taking proactive steps, you can protect yourself and your organization from doxing.

The Impact of Doxxing

Credit: youtube.com, The Charlie Kirk Shock Doctrine - The Doxxing Wars Are Here

Doxing can affect someone's mental health, professional life, and physical health in extreme cases. Living with the threat of being doxed or actually getting doxed can cause feelings of overwhelming anxiety.

This anxiety can impact mental health and last for the duration that the content is being displayed online or for as long as the victim is still receiving harassment and abuse. Only a fraction of people would have actually seen the content being shared, but it can feel like the entire world has gained access to the most private details of their personal life.

Long-term anxiety and distress can aggravate pre-existing mental health problems and potentially even lead to mental illnesses such as depression and self-harm. The victim may become worried about leaving or going outside if their home address has been shared.

Assessing any potential threat to personal safety and contacting the relevant authorities is crucial if your personal information, such as your home address, is being shared or distributed online.

What to Do If You're Doxed?

Credit: youtube.com, What to do if you become a victim of doxing?

If you've been doxed, the first thing to remember is that the situation can be resolved. Fortunately, doxing breaches the terms of service for social media accounts and blog platforms; they will normally suspend the account doing the doxing and remove the content pretty quickly.

Change all your passwords immediately to take back control of your personal security. This is because most breaches happen when your passwords or accounts get compromised.

Report the content and users to the appropriate platforms, using Google keywords from your personal information to compile a list of the platforms you need to contact. Ask for the content to be removed.

It can feel like the entire world has seen the data that's being shared, but in reality, how many people have actually read that content, or how many of them really know you?

Preventing Doxxing

Doxing is a mainstream harassment tactic that targets both high and low-profile victims, and it's essential to take proactive steps to protect yourself.

Credit: youtube.com, How to Avoid Being Doxxed

You can start by being aware of the private information you're sharing online and refraining from publicly providing sensitive details like your address, personal phone number, or email address.

Skilled hackers often use advanced tools to gather data across the internet and build a targeting profile for their victims.

Review your social media profiles and security settings to prevent your information from becoming publicly available, and think back to old usernames or abandoned social media profiles you no longer use – search them in Google and delete things that you wouldn't want there now.

To maintain your online safety and security, consider going through your social media profiles and reviewing your security settings to prevent your information from becoming publicly available.

Here are some steps you can take to prevent doxing:

  • Be mindful of the information you share on social media.
  • Keep your personal info private, especially your address and phone number.
  • Review and secure your online presence, including old usernames and abandoned social media profiles.
  • Use strong passwords and keep them confidential.

Using Doxed Information

Doxed information can be used in various ways to cause harm and distress.

Doxing on social media can lead to further harassment and help others find more information about you and your activities. This is often the first step in doxing, following existing social media bullying and abuse.

Credit: youtube.com, Investigating the Discord Exploit that Leaks Your IP!

Avoid clicking on suspicious or unusual links, as they may contain viruses. People may try to get you to download viruses to access your personal information.

Doxing of your home address can lead to serious problems, including assault, swatting, or stalking. This is particularly concerning for victims with a prominent public profile, who may be driven from their homes.

Harassment involving your place of work or study can be particularly stressful, affecting your professional reputation. False deliveries and hoax calls can be damaging to your role, and employers or administrators may decide to let you go to avoid the problem.

Leaked phone numbers can be used to stress and harass victims through hoaxes and abusive phone calls and text messages. Abusers may call you themselves or sign your number up for services to cause irritation.

Doxing of financial details, such as credit card information and account numbers, should be reported immediately to your bank. Your bank will be able to provide you with advice on how to deal with the situation and secure your account.

Judith Lang

Senior Assigning Editor

Judith Lang is a seasoned Assigning Editor with a passion for curating engaging content for readers. With a keen eye for detail, she has successfully managed a wide range of article categories, from technology and software to education and career development. Judith's expertise lies in assigning and editing articles that cater to the needs of modern professionals, providing them with valuable insights and knowledge to stay ahead in their fields.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.